Thomas Slit Image Test
Overview Computations Setup
Baldwin On TSIT Robinson On TSIT Contact


SIT_conic_20.xlsm overview

Jeff Baldwin's youtube video - taking a TSIT image
Jeff Baldwin's youtube video - processing a TSIT image

download TSIT_Conic.xlsm

Go back in time for TSIT_Parabolic.xlsm

click to download the 24 mega byte imageJ input tif file to be used with SlitTest.xlsm
  • Olympus E300 Evolt
       Lens mount to CCD: 38.8 mm
       Pixels/inch: 4771
  • Canon T2i EOS Rebel
       Lens mount to CCD: 44 mm
       Pixels/inch: 5905
FigureXp results

Conic Equations [6]

Conic equations

TSIT Conic Equations

SIT fixed equations

From the ImageJ slit values, TSIT computes the Y's - the differences between each zone pair slit images in inches. TSIT nonlinear algebraic equations compute Yi as a function of Z (the Foucaults). Next Excel's Solver is used to find the value of Z such that the difference between Yi and Y is nearly zero. Then Sixtests or FigureXp can be used to compute the mirror surface from the Foucault's.

Mask tests are of two verities, Moving or Fixed Source. The Lateral Wire Test is a Moving Source test. TSIT is a Fixed Source test where the camera and source are separated, and as such an exact solution is required rather than an approximation.

To compute the Yi of Fig: Conic fixed source need equations for variables n and Yn of Fig: TSIT n and Yn. The derivation for n proceeds using the equation of a straight line y=mx+b where slope m is slope u, the normal to the conic surface (z') and b = z's. From this then, [1]: Yu=-z'x+z's. Next to compute Yv need to know the slope of v (the perpendicular to u), which is the inverse of the slope of u i.e., 1/z' (see proof below).

Then [2]: Yv=X/z'-l/z'. Next find the intersection of lines u and v which is the solution of the simultaneous equations Yv and Yu i.e., [3]: Yv=Yu, which leads to the solution [4]: n=2(l-Kzz'^2)/(1+z'^2)-l. And then knowing n, [5]: Yn=(n-l)/z'.

Now knowing n, and Yn, can solve for Yi of Fig: Conic fixed source if we knew z. From the Conic Equations z = Z/-K, where Z is the Foucault. As stated above, Excel's Solver is used to find the value of Z such that the difference between Yi and Y is nearly zero.

TSIT Simulation

To compute the simulated Y's perfect Foucault's are input to the TSIT equations. Sixtests Caustic has been used as a cross check verification of the TSIT equations, being Sixtests solution is mathematically different, computing the surface. Sixtests formulation is differential equations which are solved numerically using Runge-Kutta (http://www.raddobs.com/atm/atm_math.htm). Whereas TSIT equations are algebraic nonlinear, computing the Foucault's.

Besides the Yi's, Sixtests requires the source distance to the mirror, l and Offset X, q (of Fig: Conic fixed source), which the TSIT spreadsheet provides. Like with standard Foucault, the source distance, l is not needed, being when the Foucault's are computed relative to a zone (typically the 70% - TSIT uses the Edge Zone), the source distance l cancels out.

The sum of the angles in a triangle is 180 degrees. The angles in the two large right triangles are the same, being the sides are the same. Angles a and b of the small triangle are the same as that of the large right triangles. Therefore the small triangle is also a right triangle and the slopes (hypotenuses) are at right angles.

SIT n and y

SIT Conic Mask Parallax



References
  [1]  
Karine and Jean-MarcLecleire, A Manual for Amateur Telescope Making. http://www.willbell.com/tm/atmmanual/index.htm
  [2]  
Kodak Spec KAF-8300CE
  [3]  
http://www.filmlabs.org/deadlinks/mounts.htmLens mount to CCD spacing
   Recommend saving this webpage to your computer, since it has vanished in the past.
  [4]  
Jim Burrows Sixtests.exe
  [5]  
Foucault Test by Leon Foucault 1858 http://bobmay.astronomy.net/foucault/leontop.htm
  [6]  Conics
Optical Shop Testing Edited by Daniel Malacara, Wiley and Sons, 1978, Appendix 1 page 479, 482
Conic approximation
Conic equations
Conic constant - Schwarzschild constant
  [7]  LWT

J. Francis, "Improved Test Methods for Elliptical and Spherical TCT Mirrors,", ATM J. 14, 34-39, (ISSN 1074-2697).

Unfortunately, references to the LWT on the Internet have mostly faded away. Jim Burrows author of Sixtests.exe does mention the LWT in passing at http://www.raddobs.com/atm/atm_math.htm. LWT was a variant of the moving source Caustic where instead of trying to determine a Caustic zone holes focus laterally and longitudinally precisely, the LWT measurements were done manually in the same lateral plane. Being that for the LWT the longitudinal value was irrelevant, didn't require a mask and little judgment was required to determine laterally where a zone ray crossed the lateral plane, the LWT was an improvement over the standard Caustic. However, the required lateral accuracy required was very tight. Given small room temperature and the time to take the measurements, I could not get repeatable LWT results.


next - Setup
Previous - Overview


© 2005 - 2018 Bill Thomas
Contact Bill Thomas